Herkimer County teacher salaries, 2024-25
Herkimer County's 846 classroom teachers earned an average of $65,408 in 2024-25, 52nd of New York's 57 counties outside New York City. The district that pays new teachers best and the one that pays long-serving teachers best are at opposite ends of the scale.
What is the average teacher salary in Herkimer County?
- County rank
- 52nd
- of 57 New York counties outside New York City
- Classroom teachers
- 846
- in 11 school districts and BOCES
- Median district
- $66,891
- Half the county's school districts pay a lower average
New Herkimer teachers earn most at Poland, veterans at Frankfort-Schuyler
Teachers with a master’s and 1 to 5 years of experience earned a median $63,538 at Poland Central School District, the most in the county and above the typical New York district’s $60,878. At Frankfort-Schuyler, the same group earned $45,862, $17,676 less.
Later in a career the order flips. Frankfort-Schuyler’s teachers with a master’s and 21 to 25 years earned $85,436, the most of any Herkimer district for that group, and $91,132 with 26 to 30 years. Poland’s 26-to-30-year group earned $79,244, $11,888 less. Someone starting out does better at Poland; someone with 25 years of experience does better at Frankfort-Schuyler.
The two districts’ averages are close: $70,320 at Poland, $68,464 at Frankfort-Schuyler. Both trail Town of Webb, the top-paying district at $73,583, where 59% of teachers hold a master’s or more.
How far behind its neighbors is Herkimer?
Every county on its border pays more. Oneida pays the most of them, $75,895 on average, $10,487 above Herkimer. Montgomery and Hamilton pay about $9,000 more. Only Otsego is level, $91 ahead.
Teacher pay in every Herkimer County school district
Average and median salary of classroom teachers, 2024-25, highest first. Districts with fewer than 20 classroom teachers have no page of their own.1
| District | Average salary | Median | Teachers | Over 10 years | Master's or more |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Town of Webb Union Free School District | $73,583 | $75,674 | 27 | 63% | 59% |
| Central Valley Central School District at Ilion-Mohawk | $70,728 | $69,176 | 177 | 66% | 71% |
| Poland Central School District | $70,320 | $71,634 | 50 | 62% | 88% |
| Frankfort-Schuyler Central School District | $68,464 | $70,164 | 66 | 70% | 86% |
| Mount Markham Central School District | $68,101 | $70,722 | 97 | 58% | 80% |
| Dolgeville Central School District | $65,681 | $64,719 | 77 | 60% | 68% |
| Little Falls City School District | $64,744 | $64,571 | 97 | 66% | 86% |
| West Canada Valley Central School District | $62,725 | $58,608 | 63 | 51% | 74% |
| Herkimer Central School District | $60,009 | $57,288 | 97 | 50% | 80% |
| Herkimer-Fulton-Hamilton-Otsego BOCES | $55,041 | $53,032 | 68 | 0% | 43% |
| Van Hornesville-Owen D. Young Central School District | $49,491 | $51,177 | 27 | 25% | 43% |
Questions about teacher pay in Herkimer County
How much do teachers make in Herkimer County, New York?
Classroom teachers in Herkimer County's 11 school districts and BOCES earned an average of $65,408 in the 2024-25 school year, $33,009 less than the New York average.
Which Herkimer County school district pays teachers the most?
Town of Webb Union Free School District, where classroom teachers earned an average of $73,583 in 2024-25.
Average teacher salaries in Herkimer County compared to nearby counties
Average classroom teacher salary in each county that borders Herkimer County, and how much more or less it pays.1
- Oneida County$75,895 average, 17 school districts and BOCES$10,487 more than Herkimer County
- Montgomery County$74,394 average, 6 school districts and BOCES$8,986 more than Herkimer County
- Hamilton County$74,211 average, 4 school districts$8,803 more than Herkimer County
- Fulton County$72,835 average, 6 school districts$7,427 more than Herkimer County
- St. Lawrence County$69,088 average, 18 school districts and BOCES$3,680 more than Herkimer County
- Lewis County$67,603 average, 5 school districts$2,195 more than Herkimer County
- Otsego County$65,499 average, 12 school districts$91 more than Herkimer County
Sources for the Herkimer County figures
Actual salaries of classroom teachers, teachers assigned to at least one course, as counted by the State Education Department. Every figure covers at least 5 teachers.
- New York State Education Department, Personnel Master File statistical run 2024-25: classroom teachers' pay, years of experience and degrees in each school district.